I agree with your assessment of last night's show--the only thing that could have possibly made it any better would have been an unexpected cover song. The venue was cool (with the minor exception of that disco ball giving the bar a couples' skate/junior high dance vibe), the crowd was awesome, and the setlist was great too. Speaking of which....I, too, am terrible at remembering these things but my friend nabbed a legit setlist--which said "ALB, NM" at the top, by the way.

Hollywood Bass Player
Pilgrim
Givin' It Up
Why Won't You Tell Me What
Comeback
Slaveship (yeah!)
His Majesty Rides
God Please Let Me Go Back
Carolina
Sweetie
1972
My Love Has Gone
It Looks Like Love
It's The Nighttime
-Encore-
Quiet Town
London Bridges*
Sad Eyes
*This might be numerous bottles of Stella talking, but I don't recall "London Bridges" being played; however I do remember "Nice To Fit In" sometime during the show.